Dedicated to women's health and well-being

Share

Add A New Comment2 Comments

Diane Porter

Susan, that's a fascinating post.

I have never heard the term third-hand smoke, but it makes sense. I know that if we go to a restaurant where the non-smoking and smoking sections are not well separated, my clothes (and long hair) smell like I was the one smoking. It makes sense -- fibers have rippled surfaces and make it easy to trap anything from dirt to fragrance to smoke.

I was raised in a smoking home (and, what I think is worse because it's such a confined space, a smoking car) -- my dad was a smoker until I was probably 16 -- and I know my health and that of my siblings was probably affected by it. All of us have had severe respiratory issues from time to time, and two of us have asthma. I don't know if secondhand smoke caused it, but it wouldn't surprise me.

That said, I think we get into a very dangerous area when we legislate what people can and cannot do within their own homes. I would guess that those who are for the ban would say that smoke in a home is an assault on a child's health just like physical abuse is an assault on a child's health and well-being.

But how would they possibly hope to enforce such a ban?

Would we then ban high-fat foods from homes where the children seem overweight? Could it be considered abuse if the parents served high-fat food?

Could it be considered neglect if a family didn't feed their children lean meat or fresh vegetables? (What if they were too poor?)

We know we must buckle children into safety seats. But could it be considered endangering a child if we have a sports car instead of a larger car that's been proven to be more safe?

While I detest smoke, and feel for those who can't get away from it, it seems unrealistic to hope that it could ever be banned inside a person's home. (Look how difficult it still is in some areas just to get it banned in public areas).

Alison Beaver

I agree that a ban on smoking in the home is impossible to enforce (whether the smoke is from from mainstream smoke, sidestream smoke, second-hand or third-hand passive smoking), caretakers of children need to be well informed of this new information and enforce a non-smoking ban in their home for their own family.

Many parents have discarded some plastic baby bottles that released harmful chemicals. Many other parents avoided artificial Christmas trees this year, as they heeded the warning that some trees contain lead. Do these same safety-conscious parents know that passive smoke (whether second- or third-hand) contains LEAD...as well as 250 additional types of poisonous gases, chemicals and metals?! Some of them include carbon monoxide, butane, ammonia, toluene (found in paint thinners), arsenic (rat poison), lead, chromium (used to make steel), cadmium (used to make batteries), and polonium-210 (a highly radioactive carcinogen).

So, while a state or government home-ban may not be enforceable, parents and caregivers can absolutely ban the use of tobacco in their homes, in order to keep their child(ren) safe! If they are traveling, parents can choose to keep their child away from these harmful chemicals (just like they would not take their child to a house with asbestos, lead or other known harmful substance) by staying with non-smoking relatives and/or at a non-smoking hotel.

Log in

Are you a member? Log in first to track your posts

Not a member? Join us. Membership is not required to post.

More information about formatting options

We never share email addresses with third parties. Your email address will be used to notify you of activity on your post and send you our newsletter if you choose to sign up for it.
Verify that you are a human (not a computer):
This is necessary to prevent computer programs from automatically posting spam or other irrelevant content on EmpowHER.com. Enter the characters in the box to the left (case sensitive). Do not enter spaces between the characters.
Image CAPTCHA

What Do YOU Think? We want to know so we can help!

Poll
Do you have sleep apnea?:
View Results

Free Weekly Newsletter

Sign up for EmpowHER's weekly newsletter