Improved
6112 HealthChanged
3786 LivesSaved
3568 Lives0 lives impacted in the last 24 hrs Learn More
To me, it is one of the most annoying habits a person can have: knuckle-cracking. Two of my boys do it frequently and I find myself continually telling them to kick that habit for fear of the long-term effects it might have on their joints. After all, when you crack your knuckles, you are at an increased risk of developing arthritis, right?
While knuckle-cracking is a highly prevalent habit among many, the research between this habit and arthritis is not as great. Dr. Peter Bonafede, medical director of the Providence Arthritis Center at Providence Portland Medical Center in Oregon, suggests that there is “likely not” a link between the cracking of one’s knuckles and later development of arthritis.
“While the arthritis connection may be an old wives’ tale, cracking your knuckles can hurt your hand in other ways, and there is no benefit to it,” said Dr. Bonafede. Kids typically develop this annoying habit because they like the way it sounds. That cracking noise heard when one cracks his knuckles is a result of a change in the synovial fluid, which is the lubricant that bathes the joints.
“When finger bones are suddenly stretched apart, the space between the joints widens and an air bubble forms in the synovial fluid. This bubble quickly bursts and makes a sharp sound,” noted Dr. Bonafede.
It is not natural for people to repeatedly stretch the ligaments of their finger joints. Certain medical studies have highlighted cases of patients who injured their hands from constant knuckle-cracking. One individual had over-stretched his ligaments and dislocated his fingers. Another patient had partially torn the ligament in her thumb.
In 1990, research was done through observation of hand function in 200 adults, age 45 and above. Although the contributing researcher could not find a greater tendency towards the development of arthritis in the 74 candidates who were habitual knuckle-crackers, he did discover that they had more conditions of swollen hands and reduced strength in their hands. However, the opposition to this theory stated that perhaps a person who can crack his or her knuckles in the first place must have ligaments that are looser than normal, and such loose ligaments and joints are setting the stage for problems down the road.
Another studied conducted in 1975 in an old age home asked residents if they had cracked their knuckles when they were younger. 15 residents recalled engaging in such a habit and 13 indicated they had never cracked their knuckles while growing up. Upon x-raying these individuals’ hands, there were no differences evident in the related arthritis rates between the knuckle-crackers and the non-knuckle-crackers.
So, while this all may suggest that cracking one’s knuckles does not contribute to the development of arthritis, it is still an annoying habit that could potentially produce other problems later in life. Right now, my boys’ main problem is listening to me constantly reminding them to “stop that!” I am one of these people who has never cracked her knuckles. I don’t belch, either. Hmmmm -- wonder what the long-term effects of that are? I may have yet another case for uttering the words “stop that!”
(Information for this article was found at http://www.providence.org/oregon/health_resource_centers/arthritis/askanexpert_arthritis_knuckles.htm)
Add a Comment2 Comments
Thanks, Pat! I have yet to even attempt to crack one of my knuckles...makes me queasy even thinking about it. Living in a houseful of boys, I hear a lot of it, not to mention all those other strange noises boys make!
January 4, 2010 - 7:36pmThis Comment
Hi Ann - Whether it's linked to arthritis or not, I'm in agreement with you - being around knuckle-cracking is obnoxious! It's good to have the data on the harm it can cause and be able to use it to help others, in a positive way, see why they should knock off the knuckle-cracking. Thanks! Pat
January 4, 2010 - 6:05pmThis Comment