This is the kind of response I expect. Low quality studies with small numbers or not actually testing directly for efficscy. This is why meta-analysis with a admission criteria based on size, replication, verification and quality (double blind etc) are used to eliminate cherry picking.
And as for not possibly surviving 200 year if it didn't work, well I guess I'll have to bring up rain dancing againg, or voodoo, or sacrificing virgins to harvest gods, or snake handling, or Opposing religions (are they all right) or exorcisms. All have long pedigrees most still going on today.
And Dana, bless him. It's not his shilling for Homeopathy, his trouble with the law for practicing medicine without a licence or his own misinformation campaign that bothers me. It's the fact that he cannot answer a straight question, perhaps you will.
Do you acknowledge that a 12 C remedy contains 1 part tincture to 10^23 parts solution and is equivalent to about 6 drop per Atlantic ocean? And that a remedy whose ratio is higher than this is unlikely to contain one molecule of the original substance?
I understand theories on the mechanism if homeopathy are not restricted to its molecular presence but by an energy imprint in the water, buy fo you accept those points?
Comment Reply
This is the kind of response I expect. Low quality studies with small numbers or not actually testing directly for efficscy. This is why meta-analysis with a admission criteria based on size, replication, verification and quality (double blind etc) are used to eliminate cherry picking.
And as for not possibly surviving 200 year if it didn't work, well I guess I'll have to bring up rain dancing againg, or voodoo, or sacrificing virgins to harvest gods, or snake handling, or Opposing religions (are they all right) or exorcisms. All have long pedigrees most still going on today.
And Dana, bless him. It's not his shilling for Homeopathy, his trouble with the law for practicing medicine without a licence or his own misinformation campaign that bothers me. It's the fact that he cannot answer a straight question, perhaps you will.
Do you acknowledge that a 12 C remedy contains 1 part tincture to 10^23 parts solution and is equivalent to about 6 drop per Atlantic ocean? And that a remedy whose ratio is higher than this is unlikely to contain one molecule of the original substance?
I understand theories on the mechanism if homeopathy are not restricted to its molecular presence but by an energy imprint in the water, buy fo you accept those points?
February 8, 2012 - 8:34pmThis Comment
Reply