Dedicated to women's health and well-being

HerArticle

Compulsive Overeating and Binge Eating for Women: Is There A Difference?

November 24, 2009 - 6:44am 298 reads 0 comments

Compulsive overeating and binge eating are most often discussed as if they were identical. However, Dr. Carolyn Ross M. D., M. P. H., explained on Empowher.com that compulsive eating is different from binge eating. But they share the one similarity: Both compulsive and binge eaters may become obese. Dr Ross adds that “People with obesity [compulsive overeaters] may overeat at every meal, but they may not have this characteristic of eating a large quantity food in one setting.” And they also do not share the binge eaters feelings of shame and guilt.

The U. S. Department of Human Services website lists five symptoms of binge eating:

· Eat much more quickly than usual during binge episodes

· Eat until they are uncomfortably full

· Eat large amounts of food even when they are not really

hungry

· Eat alone because they are embarrassed about the amount of food they eat

· Feel disgusted, depressed, or guilty after overeating

It’s one thing to know the differences between compulsive overeating and binge eating. Yet it is quite another to know the reasons that compel the compulsive or binge eater to put their health and even their lives at risk to fill themselves with so much food.

Some say, binge or compulsive overeaters try to fill a void from a long past-emotional trauma that wasn’t dealt with. Others say, it’s an addiction to food, pure and simple. Others might say, it’s genetics. But whatever it is, we know it is complicated condition, and women who find themselves with these disorders must not ignore them or “just live with it.” There is help. But no quick fixes here. Judy Lightstone, a licensed Family, and Child Counselor, describes the eating disordered woman’s typical first visit to her office on edreferral.com.

Lightstone said, “…I listen to them carefully as they describe their eating in detail to me…. You [her patient] may have a lot to say, or you may be so nervous that you don't know what say.

Add A New Comment

We value and respect the experiences of all of our HERWriters, but everyone is different. Many of our writers are speaking from personal experience, and what's worked for them may not work for you. Their articles are not a substitute for medical advice although we hope you can gain knowledge from their insight.

Start Asking & Sharing

Add A New CommentComments

There are no comments yet. Be the first to get the conversation started.

Log in

Are you a member? Log in first to track your posts

Not a member? Join us. Membership is not required to post.

More information about formatting options

We never share email addresses with third parties. Your email address will be used to notify you of activity on your post and send you our newsletter if you choose to sign up for it.
Verify that you are a human (not a computer):
This is necessary to prevent computer programs from automatically posting spam or other irrelevant content on EmpowHER.com. Enter the characters in the box to the left (case sensitive). Do not enter spaces between the characters.
Image CAPTCHA

What Do YOU Think? We want to know so we can help!

Poll
With last week's poll in mind, have *you* ever fibbed about how often you have sex with your spouse or partner?:
View Results

Free Weekly Newsletter

Sign up for EmpowHER's weekly newsletter

Health Events Search for health related events in your area

Walgreens Take Care Clinic - Phoenix

Provided by Walgreens

Welcome to Take Care Clinic We're here to bring everyday family healthcare to your neighborhood drug store. No appointments, no long waits, open 7 days a week and weeknights too. Most insurance welcome. It's personalized attention when you need it.

When:
February 20, 2010, 9:30am - 5:00pm
Where:
3450 W. Dunlap Road
3450 W. Dunlap Road
Phoenix, AZ  85051