Facebook Pixel

Is Being Self-Centered a Bad Thing?

By HERWriter
Rate This
Mental Health related image Photo: Getty Images

The holidays are usually associated with giving to others and being selfless. However, in the American culture, individualism and independence are encouraged throughout the rest of the year, so it can be difficult to just turn that off.

Although we’re almost forced to put ourselves first in this society in order to succeed, being self-centered isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. Some experts weigh in on narcissism and its relation to being self-centered, and how to recognize these qualities.

Laura Buffardi, a postdoctoral research fellow at the Universidad de Deusto in Spain, said in an e-mail that narcissism is “a trait that characterizes someone who thinks they’re pretty great. Narcissists see themselves in an overly positive way. They think they are more attractive, intelligent, and unique than others.”

Someone who is self-centered is not necessarily a narcissist, though narcissists are self-centered.

“Narcissistic people believe they are special and unique,” said Amy Brunell, an assistant psychology professor at Ohio State University at Newark. “They are arrogant, lack empathy for others, and readily take advantage of others. Narcissists have inflated, positive views of themselves, are self-centered, and are unlikely to consider how their decisions can affect others. They want others to admire them and will therefore show off and brag to get attention.”

The key is balance.

“I think there's a balance between taking care of oneself and taking care of others,” Brunell said in an e-mail. “It's a problem when one is overly self-centered. It's also unhealthy when one chronically puts the needs of others in front of his/her own.”

Like most Americans know, putting ourselves first can be vital.

“We could not survive if we didn't look out for ourselves first,” Buffardi said. “In American and other Western cultures, it is also ‘the norm’ to be self-centered because Americans have a highly independent view of themselves.”

She added that being self-centered is important in career success.

“To be competitive on the job market we must promote ourselves - or be self-centered,” Buffardi said.

There are also consumers who are self-centered, which helps drive the economy, she said.

“When there are consumers who think they deserve what they want and desire immediate gratification, there is a lot of money to be made,” Buffardi said.

However, being self-centered can be negative when it’s associated with ego-centrism.

“Being ego-centric means that you can only interpret the world in terms of your self,” Buffardi said. “Therefore, it becomes difficult to empathize with others, understand differing points of view, and compromise.”

There are certain ways a woman can tell she is being too self-centered.

“When she's so focused on herself, her beliefs, feelings, wishes, desires, etc., that she does not bother to think about others, lacks empathy for them, or fails to perspective-take,” Brunell said.

Being self-centered isn’t only a product of high self-esteem and narcissism. Those who have low self-esteem can also become self-centered.

“People with low self-esteem tend to be self-centered for different reasons - they are consumed with their negative qualities and inadequacies,” Brunell said.

Brunell said women tend to be less narcissistic than men and more communal, but Buffardi does give some suggestions for women to find out if they are being too self-centered, besides just analyzing themselves.

One way women can tell they're being too self-centered is to listen to what others have to say about them.

“If people are telling a woman that she is too self-centered, she should think about their observations,” Buffardi said. “If she is losing friends or getting into arguments with family members because they claim she is self-centered, she might want to take a step back and assess whether or not she is balancing her desires and those of close others in the best way possible.”

Those who are self-centered and narcissists aren’t necessarily a lost cause.

“In our research, we've found narcissists can become more communal (other-focused, as opposed to self-focused) when they are in long-term relationships with people who are not narcissistic,” Buffardi said. “It seems that one way for narcissists to become less self-centered involves their partners eliciting communal traits and behaviors in them over time.”

So what causes these behaviors? Brunell suggests it’s partly parenting, at least permissive parenting.

“Children learn that they can do what they want when they want and as adults they expect this pattern to continue,” Brunell said. “The self-esteem movement hasn't helped. Children were taught - and are still taught - about how they are special and unique. They get this from their families, from teachers, etc. So basically we train people from childhood to think about themselves rather than to think about others.”

Brunell said there are some ways to help prevent self-centered behavior in childhood and later on.

“We can teach children concern and empathy for others,” Brunell said. “When one child hits another, we should focus the attention on the child who got hurt … rather than on the child who misbehaved. Children would then learn care for others and how they are feeling rather than being consumed by what's happening to them in terms of their punishment.”

So what do you think? Are you too self-centered? Are you a narcissist? Do you care too much for others and forget about yourself? Or are you balanced? Do you think any of these qualities are negative or positive? Share your experiences.

Add a Comment2 Comments

EmpowHER Guest

I think self absorbtion is healthy when someone has been hurt and taken advantage of and has not recovered from their emotional abuse/trauma. This brings us back to the fundamental argument of 'givers vs. takers'. Sometimes giving too much has caused folks to be trodden on and they have vowed never to treat themselves like dirt again or allow anyone else to either. So the narcissim or self absorbtion becomes like a wall between the self and others -- a layer of protection. Moreover, if one knows what one needs and wants in life, there is no harm in being self focussed to reach those goals -- as long as no one get's hurt. The last thing to remember is that not everyone has very high affiliation needs -- these people don't need people as much as 'normal' people do -- I am an only child, and have learnt how to live alone, entertain myself, develop interests and hobbies and find people to be the source of noise and chaos. I'm happier being alone or with very few close people. It is quite reasonable to say that if another person has nothing much to teach you or contribute to your life and you have no common background, why waste time trying to fit in?

June 11, 2014 - 5:18am
EmpowHER Guest
Anonymous (reply to Anonymous)

This so sounds just like me but sometimes I feel bad because my male friends thinks I only worry about myself but I have things that I havent yet accomplished and I fee once I do that then I can think about someone else and their needs but I feel like I should focus on myself first before anyone and make sure that im in a healthy place in my life to where I feel comfortable giving a hand out

March 9, 2015 - 2:06pm
Enter the characters shown in the image.
By submitting this form, you agree to EmpowHER's terms of service and privacy policy
Add a Comment

We value and respect our HERWriters' experiences, but everyone is different. Many of our writers are speaking from personal experience, and what's worked for them may not work for you. Their articles are not a substitute for medical advice, although we hope you can gain knowledge from their insight.