Facebook Pixel

PMDD (Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder) Join this Group

Is there a difference between anti-depressants and sugar pill (placebo)?

By September 17, 2012 - 7:40pm

In case you didn't see this article or hear about the studies on antidepressants: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/22/magazine/the-science-and-history-of-treating-depression.html

Antidepressants are no better than placebo for treating depression. Strikingly, this is information the drug companies AND the FDA knew from the very first time studies were submitted to the government in order to approve the drugs (for sale in the United States.)

One prominent author (Irving Kirsch) says that this doesn't mean that antidepressants don't work at all; rather, it means placebo works really well for treating depression. He also points out that almost any drug (not just antidepressants) works for depression, even medications that LOWER serotonin (!) He also points out that counselling and therapy, and even St. John's Wort, do work better than placebo. But mostly, he says, placebo is very powerful medicine - another way of saying that our beliefs and thoughts powerfully influence our health.

Of course, no one has performed comparable studies on PMDD and SSRIs, but since - as the NY Times article points out - the theory of "neurotransmitters causing depression" is considered scientifically dead, it stands to reason that there is little or no benefit greater than that of placebo for this application of these drugs.

Dr. Daniel Heller

p.s. This research is not a reason to stop taking SSRIs if you feel they've helped you. And, if you decide you would like to discontinue them, it's essential to do so slowly and carefully under the guidance of a qualified health care practitioner.

By HERWriter Guide September 23, 2012 - 1:19pm

Thanks Dr. Heller!

This is really interesting! I was put on an SSRI for extreme Seasonal Affective Disorder last year and the side effects were absolutely awful and the meds did nothing to help. I went off them 3 months later and the withdrawal was even worse. They may work for some - I know many women who call them life-changers and savers but for me - never again!


September 23, 2012 - 1:19pm

Group Leader

Related Topics


PMDD is the most severe form of PMS. Women with PMDD can have all the same physical symptoms as PMS, but usually have very severe emotional symptoms that make life during the premenstrual phase nearly impossible. PMDD is usually treated with antidepressants or oral contraceptives. Alternative therapies also hold promise for PMDD. I am a holistic doctor who has started a website for PMS and PMDD, and have created this group to help increase awareness of PMDD and create a place where women can share openly about this difficult condition.


This Group is Open to all EmpowHER.com members