Low Carbs Versus Low Fat: A New Study Weighs In
The prevalence of
At the heart of these efforts lies the conventional high-carbohydrate, low-fat, low-calorie diet, an approach that, in the face of this lack of success, has lost popularity in recent years. However, alternatives to this conventional approach inspire sometime heated controversy, particularly the low-carbohydrate, high-protein, high-fat (Atkins) diet.
Recently, a group of researchers attempted to determine whether or not the popular low-carbohydrate diet was truly more effective for weight loss than the more conventional approach. This study, published in the May 22, 2003 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine , found that the low-carbohydrate diet produced a greater weight loss than the conventional diet for the first six months, but the differences were not significant at one year.
About the study
The researchers conducted a one-year, multicenter, controlled trial involving 63 obese men and women who were randomly assigned to either a low-carbohydrate, high-protein, high-fat diet or a low-calorie, high-carbohydrate, low-fat (conventional) diet.
Participants on the low-carbohydrate diet were instructed to limit their intake of carbohydrates to 20 grams per day for the first two weeks of the diet, and then gradually increase their carbohydrate consumption until a stable desired weight was achieved. No restrictions were placed on their consumption of protein or fat. They were also given a copy of “Dr. Atkins New Diet Revolution” and instructed to read it and follow the diet as described in the book.
Participants on the conventional diet were instructed to follow a high-carbohydrate, low-fat, low-calorie diet (women 1200-1500 calories per day; men 1500-1800 calories per day), with approximately 60% of their calories from carbohydrates, 25% from fat, and 15% from protein. These participants were given a copy of “The LEARN (lifestyle, exercise, attitudes, relationships, nutrition) Program for Weight Management” and asked to read it and follow the program as described.
The researchers found that the participants who followed the low-carbohydrate diet had lost significantly more weight at 3 and 6 months than had those following the conventional low-calorie diet. However, this difference was no longer significant by one year.
The researchers also found that the low-carbohydrate diet was associated both increased levels of HDL (good) cholesterol and decreased levels of triglycerides.
How does this affect you?
The results of this study demonstrate that the low-carbohydrate, high-fat, high-protein Atkins diet produced greater weight loss than a conventional diet for up to six months, but that this difference was not maintained for one year. This is likely due to greater weight re-gain by those participants who followed the low-carbohydrate diet and may reflect the difficulty of adhering to this type of diet over the long term. Also, one important unanswered question is the effect of limited carbohydrates and abundant fats on the risk of coronary heart disease over time. It is true that in this study, the participants on the low-carbohydrate diet demonstrated a greater improvement in some risk factors for
A second study published in the same issue of the
New England Journal of Medicine
, found that a small group of severely obese patients, all of whom were either diabetic or showed evidence of
While neither of these studies settles the debate, they certainly offer important insights into the issue. In the end, there was little to no difference in the amount of weight lost by the participants after one year, regardless of the diet plan they followed. This result seems more a testament to the difficulty of achieving long-term, permanent weight loss than an endorsement or condemnation of either diet approach. Despite our relentless search for a magic bullet, it seems our battle with obesity rages on.
American Dietetic Association
Foster GD, Wyatt HR, Hill JO, et al. A randomized trial of a low-carbohydrate diet for obesity. N Engl J Med. 2003;348:2082-2090.
Samaha FF, Iqbal N, Seshadri P, et al. A low-carbohydrate as compared with a low fat diet in severe obesity. N Engl J Med. 2003;348:2074-2081.
Last reviewed May 22, 2003 by
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.
Copyright © 2007 EBSCO Publishing All rights reserved.