While Lobbyists Lament Rationing, Patients Sometimes Want It

By Francine Hardaway Blogger July 8, 2009 - 8:11am Rate This

The health care industry is spending about $1.5 million a day on lobbying efforts in Congress. Most of those dollars are spent fighting against the threat of “rationing.” That doesn’t count the money that’s spent on TV ads in which disgruntled people from Canada tell why they come to the United States for surgery (supposedly because public plans ration care).

The rant about rationing is designed to make consumers feel that no one will be able to get in to see a doctor under a public plan and that grandma will be denied her hip replacement because she’s — heaven forbid — over 65. It’s designed to make efforts at real health care reform fail. Fear can be a powerful motivator and the lobbyists and advertising campaigns are trying desperately to evoke as much fear as they can in the mind of the consumer, hoping that will influence Congress.

What most Americans don’t realize is that our health care is rationed now. If you aren’t employed by someone who provides health insurance, your access to health care is limited by your ability to pay for it. That’s rationing. If you are insured, but your plan doesn’t cover the test your doctor thinks you need, or you think you want, your care is also rationed. It you lose your job, your care is rationed, because you probably can’t afford COBRA. Right now, people who have health insurance that’s provided by their employers feel complacent and, understandably, don’t want reform. That perspective shifts in a minute when they get sick or are unemployed.

Rationing can be done well. We can ration care that has not been proven to prolong life or to be effective. My late husband, a radiologist, used to see cancer patients all the time. One of the things that made him most upset was when a patient was given chemotherapy or radiation therapy that would make them sick immediately with only a small chance of prolonging life for a few weeks. He thought that this “standard of care” – try everything - was permanent employment for oncologists, and he often counseled his friends to refuse treatment and live well, if not healthy, until they died.

He died twelve years ago this week.

Rate This

0 comments View Comments

We value and respect the experiences of all of our HERWriters, but everyone is different. Many of our writers are speaking from personal experience, and what's worked for them may not work for you. Their articles are not a substitute for medical advice although we hope you can gain knowledge from their insight.